That’s just one of several reported transparency and related problems with the stimulus bill, but let’s tackle it first.
A sneaky text file embedded at recovery.gov initially prevented Google, and other search engines, from indexing content on the site. And, no, don’t tell me this was accidental. The file was embedded for three hours, then removed; all the biggie tech-type online mags seemed to have picked up on this.
“…(As CNET notes, the file was just three lines of text, and was written expressly for the purpose of blocking web-crawling.)
Oh, this is far and away from the first time the Obama Administration has used the robots.txt file to block crawling of various government websites.
That said, Chris Soghoian says don’t judge Team Obama’s commitment, or lack thereof, to transparency just by the robots.txt file usage.
Of course, Chris earlier commented on the White House allowing YouTube tracking cookies on government websites.
Meanwhile, uberconservative writer Byron York smells a RAT – namely, the Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board, or the RAT Board, in the stimulus bill.
If York is even half right in his worries, about how the RAT board has the power to try to get Cabinet department and Federal agency inspectors general to curtail investigations…
It’s scary. …”
http://socraticgadfly.blogspot.com/2009/02/obama-blocks-transparency-on.html
To be fair to President Obama, he is not the King Rat character in the novel or movie, but closer to the character of Robin Grey, a British officer and Provost Marshal of the prison camp.
Background Articles and Videos
King Rat the Movie
King Rat
“King Rat is a 1962 novel by James Clavell. Set during World War II, Clavell’s literary debut describes the struggle for survival of British, Australian and American prisoners of war in a Japanese camp in Singapore — a description informed by Clavell’s own three-year experience as a prisoner in the notorious Changi Prison camp. One of the major characters, Peter Marlowe, is based upon Clavell’s younger self.
Despite its fearsome reputation, Changi was historically among the better-run Japanese camps, with only 850 deaths among the 87,000 prisoners who passed through.[1]
King Rat retroactively became the first book published of Clavell’s sweeping series, the Asian Saga, and the fourth chronologically. Several main characters from King Rat appear again in Noble House. …”
“…The novel opens in early 1945. Peter Marlowe, a young British Flight Lieutenant, has been a P.O.W. since 1942. Marlowe comes to the attention of the “King,” an American corporal who has become the most successful trader and black marketeer in Changi, when the King sees him conversing in Malay. Marlowe’s language skill, intelligence, honesty, and winning personality cause the King to befriend him and attempt to involve him in black market deals. This, in turn, brings Marlowe to the attention of Robin Grey, a British officer and Provost Marshal of the camp, who has developed a Javert-like obsession with the King and hopes to arrest him for violating camp regulations. Grey is attempting to maintain strict military discipline among the prisoners and sees the King as the antithesis of everything he believes.
Despite being only an enlisted man and without distinction in civilian life, the King has become a major power in the enclosed society of the P.O.W. camp through his charisma and intelligence. Trading with Korean guards, local Malay villagers, and other prisoners for food, clothing, information, and what few luxuries are available, the King keeps himself and his fellow American prisoners alive. Even senior officers come to him for help in selling their valuables to buy extra food, and other officers are secretly on his payroll.
Grey, the son of a working class family, is a legal positivist, following the rules for their own sake, and using his position as Provost Marshal to gain a status otherwise unavailable to him in British society. …”
“…The novel can be understood as an examination of the ethics of individualism and natural law in opposition to collectivism and legal positivism. In this sense, the novel takes on a certain amount of political significance in that it establishes two forms of political ideology that Clavell would explore in his entire Asian Saga series. The King relies on free trade to survive, in which he reaps the most reward, although he does help all the men who are associated with him. On the other hand, the system Grey attempts to enforce is one of Socialistic equality in that every man would only get an equal share what was rationed by their captors, regardless of individual merit. …”
In recent years, some critics have compared the philosophy and character of the King to that of Ayn Rand’s Howard Roark from The Fountainhead. Clavell himself lent credence to this claim by sending Ayn Rand a copy of Noble House in 1981 with the following inscription – “This is for Ayn Rand – one of the real, true talents on this earth for which many, many thanks. James C, New York, 2 Sept 81.”[
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_Rat_(1962_novel)
Will We Be Able to Follow the Money?
by Jennifer LaFleur, ProPublica
“…Will Recovery.gov [1] — the oversight Web site promised in the stimulus bill — really give the public enough information about how their money is spent?
While the stimulus package passed by the House of Representatives earlier today lays out some public reporting requirements, it also leaves some wiggle room. And that’s what worries some transparency advocates.
Any direct recipient of stimulus funds must give the agencies they’ve received funds from details about their projects. Then agencies, in turn, have to make those details public. But the bill doesn’t clearly define how states and other recipients of the money will have to report information.
“These could be pdfs on recovery.gov and that wouldn’t be the kind of transparency that we would urge there being,” said Sean Moulton, director of federal information policy for OMB Watch [2]. “We wanted a strong requirement on the government to establish a standard reporting system. So you’re not getting 50 different structures.”
http://www.propublica.org/article/will-we-be-able-to-follow-the-money-090213
House Makes Transparency a Priority for Stimulus
“…Transparency and oversight in the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 extend beyond posting spending data on the Internet. The economic recovery bill establishes an “Accountability and Transparency Board.” The oversight body would be headed by the new Chief Performance Officer, Nancy Killefer, and composed of six inspectors general and/or deputy secretaries from various federal agencies. It would be charged with coordinating and conducting oversight of federal spending under the law to prevent waste, fraud, and abuse by submitting monthly reports to Congress on contract and grant awards, contractor performance, and the adequacy of contractor and acquisition oversight within the federal government.
In addition to the Board, the bill would also create an “Independent Advisory Panel” and require regular oversight by the Government Accountability Office (GAO), Congress’s investigative arm. Composed of experts in the fields of economics, public finance, and other related disciplines, the Independent Advisory Panel would be charged with advising the Accountability and Transparency Board with an aim to prevent and otherwise identify waste, fraud, and abuse related to spending under the law. The bill also appropriates $25 million to GAO for the ongoing oversight of and reporting on the stimulus bill.
OMB Watch has analyzed the bill’s transparency and accountability section and has found areas in which Congress could expand or improve the legislation as drafted. Our analysis expounds on these areas in some detail, but in short we suggest the bill stipulate that:
- Recovery.gov be open to indexing by commercial search engines
- All contract and grant transactions should be posted on USASpending.gov, with a special notation that such contracts and grants are created through the stimulus legislation
- All reports, findings, minutes and agendas of meetings, official letters and correspondence of the Board, and any data or information gathered during investigations by the Board be made publicly available and posted on Recovery.gov within five business days of the release of information …”
http://www.ombwatch.org/node/9635
Certain Firms, Industries Got Last-Minute Gifts in Stimulus
“…The political parties fought over words as well as numbers. For example, Democrats removed GOP language added in the Senate that would have barred the use of stimulus funds for stadiums, community parks, art centers, museums and highway beautification. The bill does forbid localities from using stimulus funds for casinos, aquariums, zoos, golf courses and swimming pools, but the federal government is not bound by the rule.
Sen. Charles E. Grassley (Iowa), the ranking Republican on the Senate Finance Committee, railed against a provision that he said would undermine the independence of watchdog agencies within the government. The bill sets up a new panel, the Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board, which has the authority to request “that an inspector general conduct or refrain from conducting an audit or investigation.”
“Any new limitation on the independence of inspectors general is dangerous,” Grassley said. …”
‘‘American Recovery and Reinvestment
Act of 2009’’
TITLE XV—ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY
Starts on Page 172
http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov/cgi-bin/getdoc.cgi?dbname=111_cong_bills&docid=f:h1enr.pdf
Rebel Yell: Taxpayers Revolt Against Gimme-Mania
By Michelle Malkin
Disgraced Democrat Sen. John Edwards was right about one thing: There are two Americas. One America is full of moochers, big and small, corporate and individual, trampling over themselves with their hands out demanding endless bailouts. The other America is full of disgusted, hard-working citizens getting sick of getting played for chumps and punished for practicing personal responsibility.
Now is the time for all good taxpayers to turn the tables on free-lunching countrymen and their enablers in Washington. Community organizing helped propel Barack Obama to the White House. It can work for fiscal conservatism, too. …”
http://michellemalkin.com/2009/02/20/rebel-yell-taxpayers-revolt-against-gimme-mania/
Jim Rogers On Stimulus Bill and Who is to blame for financial crisis
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Are You POed?–Pelosi Obama–Clueless Crisis Creators Cry Crisis Crisis Crisis–Gloom, Doom and Then Boom Boom Boom–When: After 2010 Elections–How Convenient! « Pronk Palisades
February 22, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
The Second Breaking Wave of Mortage Defaults–Alt+A and Option Arm Mortages–Crashes US Economy!–Videos « Pronk Palisades
February 23, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
The Second Breaking Wave of Mortgage Defaults–Alt+A and Option Arm Mortages–Crashes US Economy!–Videos « Pronk Palisades
February 23, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
President Obama Is Driving The American People Down The Highway to Socialism and Serfdom–Stop The Bus! « Pronk Palisades
February 24, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
A Fiscally Responsible President or The Flim-Flam Man–Never Trust A Lying Radical Socialist! « Pronk Palisades
February 24, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
President Obama Looking For Solutions in All The Wrong Places–Big Government: You Are No President Ronald Reagan! « Pronk Palisades
February 25, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Vice President Biden:”…stimulus program is designed to “drop-kick” the economy out of its deep recession”: Democrats vs Republicans Videos vs American People Kicking Contest « Pronk Palisades
February 25, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Vice President Biden:”…stimulus program is designed to “drop-kick” the economy out of its deep recession”: Democrats vs Republicans vs American People Kicking Contest–Videos « Pronk Palisades
February 25, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Vice President Biden: …stimulus program is designed to drop-kick the economy out of its deep recession: Democrats vs Republicans vs American People Kicking Contest–Videos « Pronk Palisades
February 26, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Liberal Fascism–Jonah Goldberg–Videos « Pronk Palisades
February 26, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Tea Parties Take Off In Texas–Spreading Nation Wide–Are You Going To Washington Fair? Millions Celebrate The Second American Revolution–Saturday, July 4, 2009 « Pronk Palisades
February 27, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Tea Parties Take Off In Texas–Spreading Nationwide–Are You Going To Washington Fair? Millions Celebrate The Second American Revolution–Saturday, July 4, 2009 « Pronk Palisades
February 27, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Operation Family Freedom (OFF): Millions Celebrate Washington Fair, Saturday, July 4, 2009–The Second American Revolution « Pronk Palisades
February 28, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Second American Revolution–Tea Party Celebrations–Washington Fair–July 4, 2009–An Open Invitation To The American People « Pronk Palisades
March 1, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Radical Welfare Socialism Assaults Free Enterprise Capitalism–The “Silent” Majority Responds! « Pronk Palisades
March 2, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Rush Limbaugh Challenges President Barack Obama to An Open Debate On His Talk Radio Show! « Pronk Palisades
March 5, 2009
[…] President Obama’s–Recovery Accountability and Transparency Board–RAT Board–King Rat’s Chic… […]
Obama’s Marxist Magic Mess–Big Bad Bonuses–Radical Socialist Sleight of Hand « Pronk Palisades
March 19, 2009